September 23,2015
Proffessor Young
English 1100
A frequent topic up for debate is if your social class molds
you in your education for future jobs. Jean Anyon wrote an essay on the topic
stating that if your poor, rich, or from a middle class family your
education is depicted because of your class, called “Social Class and the
Hidden Curriculum of Work. In the essay it discusses the fact that she believes
that your life is planned out already from your current money situation, I don’t
believe that is true. I went to what is considered to be a lower or middle
class school system for the grades Kindergarten to 8th. During these
years I found out that the amount you learn depended on the teacher you had. I
had mostly good teachers and could easily retain the information and memorize
it while friends in other classes could not. But, after 8th grade I went
to a local private school for high school and learned that the education level
was much higher than the education level for my public high school. With that
being said though I was still well prepared in the material from the public elementary
school and the public high school. The only difference I found in the curriculum
in the schools was that in my private school our standard classes were taught
the same information as the AP classes in the public high school, and even at a
faster rate than the public high school. I also figured out that the social
class your born into does not mean you will be taught at the standard of that
social class, instead the teacher and your work ethic will decide the “social
class standard” that you would be taught at. Coming from an area of mostly
working class people or blue-collared jobbed people when reading Jean Anyon’s article
this sentence stuck out, “the procedure is usually mechanical, involving rote
behavior and very little decision making or choice. The teachers rarely explain
why the work is being assigned, how it might connect to other assignments, or
what the idea is that lies behind the procedure or gives it coherence and
perhaps meaning or significance.” In the schools in my area I found this not to
be true because we were always explained what the project was and why we were given it. In my opinion your social class does not make your value of education.
While my opinion on the topic may not be the same as yours, I really like how much reasoning and experience you mentioned into your answer. It was very clear what your point was and you stood by it. Great job :)
ReplyDeleteGood job stating your point Kylie. In what specific way could you have added quotes from Jean Anyon to support your position?
ReplyDelete